From richard.l.chen@jpl.nasa.gov Tue Mar 5 03:24:46 2013 Date: Tue, 5 Mar 2013 08:24:15 +0000 From: "Chen, Richard L (388M)" To: "ludmilla@astro.umd.edu" Cc: Anne Raugh , Stephanie McLaughlin Subject: Re: PDS Small Bodies Node EPOXI and Rosetta data review These were very good. My comments are all straightforward, so if you need my attention during the telecon, you'll probably have to prod me. The . before the directory name below is just my mechanism for keeping the order of the web page - please ignore. The attached file has my suggested tweaks for references.cat for the first Rosetta dataset. Richard 1.dif-c-hrii-3_4-epoxi-hartley2-v2.0/catalog/epoxi.cat seems to be the latest version of this file. The other 7 datasets that use this file should update. 1.dif-c-hrii-3_4-epoxi-hartley2-v2.0/catalog/ref.cat - This file corrected CHRISTIANSENETAL2008 from "... K. Klassen ..." to "... K. Klaasen ..." (2 a's instead of 2 s's). FYI, the wrong one is in http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2008AAS...212.4404C - Line 376: I think "Karen, " should be removed from REFERENCE_DESC = "Belton, M.J.S., K.J, Meech, Karen, S. Chesley, - For BELTONETAL2011 (sorry, these are the nittiest of nits): old: Y.-J. Choi... M.-J. Kim... pp. 345-368 new: Y.J. Choi... M.-J.Kim... p. 345-368 1.dif-c-hrii-3_4-epoxi-hartley2-v2.0/document/*.lbl Many document/*.lbl in the first 7 datasets reference these unknown datasets: DI-C-HRII/HRIV/MRI/ITS-6-DOC-SET-V4.0 DIF-E-HRII-3/4-EPOXI-EARTH-V2.0 DIF-M-HRII-3/4-EPOXI-MARS-V1.0 1.dif-c-hrii-3_4-epoxi-hartley2-v2.0/document/epoxi_sis.* This directory's version is newer and smaller than the others'. 2.dif-c-hriv-5-epoxi-hartley2-deconv-v1.0/document Does this dataset need a SIS? Perhaps docinfo.txt could mention the EDR/RDR SIS? 3.*/catalog/dataset.cat Missing LABEL_REVISION_NOTE 4.dif-e-hriv-3_4-epoxi-earth-v2.0/calib/adclut/hrivis_000101_1_0.lbl COLUMNS = 1 should be 2 ROW_BYTES = 8 should be 13 COLUMN_NUMBER = 1 should be 2 on the second column 6.dif-m-hriv-3_4-epoxi-mars-v2.0/calib/adclut/hrivis_000101_1_0.lbl COLUMNS = 1 should be 2 ROW_BYTES = 8 should be 13 COLUMN_NUMBER = 1 should be 2 on the second column a.ro-a-osinac_osiwac-5-lutetia-shape-v1.0/catalog/dataset.cat DATA_SET_NAME = "PLATE SHAPE MODEL OF ASTEROID LUTETIA, V1.0" This is not a bug, but these values usually have no comma before the version. a.ro-a-osinac_osiwac-5-lutetia-shape-v1.0/catalog/insthost.cat To verify that this is deliberate, the end of INSTRUMENT_HOST_DESC for INSTRUMENT_HOST_ID = RL is missing: "Operational Modes: These modes define Lander operation of Experiments. ###########TO BE COMPLETED BY SONC ############" a.ro-a-osinac_osiwac-5-lutetia-shape-v1.0/catalog/references.cat minor format fixes. Attached. a.ro-a-osinac_osiwac-5-lutetia-shape-v1.0/data/lutetia_3e6_cart.lbl Line 40: BYTES = 6 is too low. The .wrl file has value "1572866", i.e. 7 chars b.ro-a-osinac_osiwac-5-steins-shape-v1.0/catalog/dataset.cat DATA_SET_NAME = "PLATE SHAPE MODEL OF ASTEROID STEINS, V1.0" This is not a bug, but these values usually have no comma before the version. c.ear-c-compil-4-unident-v1.0/data/*/*.lbl Many columns have values of all 9's. Would it be useful to define in the label INVALID_CONSTANT or MISSING_CONSTANT? [ Part 2, "references.cat" Application/OCTET-STREAM (Name: ] [ "references.cat") 2.4 KB. ] [ Unable to print this part. ]