Stardust Raw and Calibrated Review 19 August 2014
=============================

SDU-A-NAVCAM-2-EDR-ANNEFRANK-V3.0
SDU-A-NAVCAM-3-EDR-ANNEFRANK-V1.0
SDU-C-NAVCAM-2-EDR-WILD2-V3.0
SDU-C-NAVCAM-3-RDR-WILD2-V3.0

Certification Status: Certified pending lien resolution
Posting Status: When corrected.

- References need to be updated for published papers. In particular, look for 
  "TBD".  For example: "ECONOMOUETAL2011".

- Calibrated data needs to be converted to SI units.

- The various descriptions of the raw data set likely to be visible to users 
  do not actually describe the data as "raw".  They need to be explicit on 
  that point because of the large similarity with the calibrated data set 
  descriptions.

- Need a reference to the location of the calibration sources/data in any 
  calibration description/summary in, e.g., dataset.cat, calinfo.txt

- Documentation indicating when the heater was turned off/on needs to be 
  included or explicitly stated where this documentation should be found. 
  If possible, put this information in the label for each image. 

- Coherent noise bars do not appear to be reflected in the SNR map. The 
  coherent noise issue needs to be explained in some place visible to users. 

- There are fewer images in the V3.0 raw data than the V2.0 raw data.  This 
  presents a problem for migrating to PDS4, because we can't lose data in 
  the migration and registry support for PDS3 is less than minimal.  Brian 
  will supply a list of the omitted files, at a minimum.  If it is possible 
  to carry along the extra files in the raw data sets without substantial 
  effort, that would be preferable.

- browse/ 

    - Browinfo.txt should include an explanation for the "><" in the images 
      or reference the file that discusses it.

    - A mention of the frames being windowed should be included under 
      Browinfo.txt as well as under Dataset.cat

- calib/nc_*_shutter.lbl

    - Second definition of HEADER should be deleted (line 44).

- catalog/dataset.cat 

    - ABSTRACT_DESC: The possibility of calibration changes between missions 
      need to be addressed.  
    
    - The paragraph "N.B The periscope was not used for the Annefrank 
      encounter..." is repeated. 

    - DATA_PRODUCER and author for the CITATION_DESCRIPTION need to be 
      modified.

    - sdu-a-navcam-3-rdr-annefrank-v1.0/catalog/dataset.cat
  
        - DATA_SET_NAME = "STARDUST NAVCAM CALIBRATED IMAGES OF ANNEFRANK" 
          needs a version number.

- data/datainfo.txt

    - "/DATA/ directory layout" doesn't reflect what was distributed, not 
      "/DATA/EDR/APPROACH" but data/approach/<yyyy>/<mm>_<dd> (line 138).

- document/

    -Docinfo.txt

        - Listed files are not in any specified order.

        - Piimglog* and Nextnavcamflightlog* are not listed.

    - Nc_cal_overview.htm
        
        - DCMP: COMPATBL.LBL isn't present.

        - "Compression lookup table in NAVCAM ROM" needs an explanation.
        
        - BIAS calculation: There is no indication which of two temperatures 
          (FOPLTEMP and SCMBTEMP) in the label is the correct one to use in 
          the bias calculation. This needs to be stated.

    - nextnavcamflightlog.xls has no text version. Try replacing .xls with 
      .csv

- extras/pdsdd_new.full

    - For NAME = "SDU:TARGET_RIGHTUPOFFSETWRTLEFTBOT" the following line 
      NAME = "DAWN:CALLAMP_DUTY" seems left over

    - GENERAL_DATA_TYPE = REAL should probably be = INTEGER with a minimum 
      value of 0

- voldesc.cat
    - VOLUME_VERSION_ID needs to be updated to "VERSION 3" for the version 3
      data sets.


Prepared by M. Reiser.  Edited by T. Barnes on 2015-09-30.