[ERROR] means that there is an error that needs to be fixed. [WARN] means that there is an error that may be ignored or that there might be an error present. =============================================== NOTE: (1) This is the last delivery of these data sets before the review. Last delivery was 2014-06-25. =============================================== Datasets Validated: SDU-A-NAVCAM-2-EDR-ANNEFRANK-V3.0 SDU-A-NAVCAM-3-RDR-ANNEFRANK-V1.0 SDU-C-NAVCAM-2-EDR-WILD2-V3.0 SDU-C-NAVCAM-3-RDR-WILD2-V3.0 =============================================== Errors for: All datasets [WARN] file: 'catalog/dataset.cat' --> The ABSTRACT_DESC from the data set catalog file mentions that this data set contains only a subset of an existing data set. Is that original data set an earlier version? Has any of the data been missed that should have been included? --> In the ABSTRACT_DESC it describes there being a previous version. Should we specify what that version was, or what the current version is for clarity? --> In the CITATION_DESC, the 'author(s)' have changed from previous versions of the data set. Is this correct? --> --> Annefrank: "Semenov, B.V., T.L. Farnham, R.L. Newburn, H.W. Taylor, C. Hash, and C.H. Acton" from the supposed superseded data set to "A'Hearn, M.F., et al." in this current version. --> --> Wild2: "Semenov, B.V., T.L. Farnham, R.L. Newburn, H.W. Taylor, C. Hash, and C.H. Acton" for EDR and "R.L. NEWBURN, T.L. FARNHAM" for RDR from the supposed superseded data sets to "A'Hearn, M.F., et al." in this current version. [WARN] file: 'catalog/next.cat' --> The mission "NEXT" is not referenced in any other non-mission catalog file. Should we remove this catalog file from the data sets? --> --> If you delete this file, please remember to remove the reference from 'voldesc.cat'. --> --> Brian's response: =============== The post-NExT STARDUST.CAT mission catalog file contains two references similar to this: Stardust-NExT extended mission ------------------------------ In 2007, the Stardust spacecraft was re-directed to and encounter with comet 9P/Tempel 1. Details of that mission are in the NEXT.CAT mission catalog. so I included NEXT.CAT in an effort to make the data sets more self-contained. I didn't want to use a pre-NExT STARDUST.CAT, without those references, or eliminate those references, because that might wipe out the newer one at EN (that might not be an issue but I remembered the mess I caused with TARGET_CATALOGs). Would it be better if I moved NEXT.CAT out of CATALOG/ and put it into DOCUMENT/ as NEXT_CAT.TXT? Hmm, then it sounds like DOCUMENT/NEXT_CAT.TXT is the way to go, just to provide a target for the reference in CATALOG/STARDUST.CAT. ================ [ERROR] file: 'catalog/reference.cat' --> The reference key ECONOMOUETAL2011 has a lot of TBD values. This reference is for back in 2011, has the details been figured out by 2014? [ERROR] file: 'voldesc.cat' --> VOLUME_VERSION_ID is wrong for most data sets. For all V3.0 data sets, it should be "VERSION 3". "VERSION 1" is already being used by the v1.0 of these data sets.