[ERROR] means that there is an error that needs to be fixed.
[WARN] means that there may be an error or that there is an error that may be ignored.
[DISCUSS] should be brought in the review for discussion.

===============================================
NOTE:

(1) This is a sample delivery.

(2) Note the items with "(Maud fix)" that signify a fix made by Maud prior to posting for the review.


===============================================
Datasets Validated:
	RO-C-RPCICA-3-ESC1-CALIB-V1.0


===============================================
Errors for:	RO-C-RPCICA-3-ESC1-CALIB-V1.0

[SUGGEST] directory: 'CALIB/'
--> Suggest making subdirectories for each grouping of files to make this directory easier to parse.

[SUGGEST] files: 'CALIB/*.LBL
--> Suggest adding FORMAT keyword to columns that do not currently contain this keyword (most columns in most files) where appropriate.

[SUGGEST] file: 'CALIB/CALINFO.TXT'
--> Suggest abbreviating each grouping of files with a generic file description.

[ERROR] files: 'CALIB/GFACTOR_*.LBL'
--> (Maud fix) Change RECORD_BYTES from 100 to 49.

[ERROR] file: 'CALIB/ICA_ENERGY_TABLE_V07.LBL'
--> (Maud fix) Update FILE_RECORDS and ROWS from 96 to 32

[ERROR] file: 'CALIB/ICA_ENERGY_TABLE_V08.LBL'
--> (Maud fix) Update FILE_RECORDS and ROWS from 96 to 8

[ERROR] files: 'CALIB/ICA_MASK_*.LBL'
--> The ITEM_BYTES and ITEM_OFFSET should each be reduced by 1.  So for example, for file: ICA_MASK_HEAVY_BST_P1_V06.LBL, ITEM_BYTES = 1 and ITEM_OFFSET = 2, as opposed = 2 and = 3.

[ERROR] file: 'CATALOG/DATASET.CAT'
--> (Maud fixes)  Maud many several fixes.  Please confirm that they are correct.  At least one was not.
--> When the data set is complete (not just sample), ensure that START_TIME and STOP_TIME values are correct (encompass those found in data products and mission phase).
--> The ABSTRACT_DESC should make mention of the mission phase and/or time range the data was taken.
--> The CITATION_DESC should contain the correct DATA_SET_ID, "RO-C-RPCICA-3-ESC1-CALIB-V1.0".

[WARN] files: 'DATA/CALIBRATED/2014/NOV/D28/*.LBL'
--> [DISCUSS] Several of these keywords seem much more precise than is possible to know.  Please do not over exaggerate your precision.
--> --> Known affected keywords: SC_SUN_POSITION_VECTOR, SC_TARGET_POSITION_VECTOR, SC_TARGET_VELOCITY_VECTOR, SPACECRAFT_ALTITUDE, SUB_SPACECRAFT_LATITUDE, SUB_SPACECRAFT_LONGITUDE

[ERROR] files: 'DATA/CALIBRATED/2014/NOV/D28/*.LBL'
--> Column 1 UNIT is wrong.  This is a full date/time value which is NOT given in seconds but in year, month, day, hour, minute, and seconds.  Please remove this keyword or specify "N/A" as the value.
--> Recommend adding a format keyword to column 1: FORMAT = "A26".
--> The last column has the wrong FORMAT.  Should be FORMAT = "96(E7.3)" since there are 96 items.

[ERROR] file: 'VOLDESC.CAT'
--> The VOLUME_ID "ROICA_1010" is currently be used by RO-C-RPCICA-2-ESC1-RAW-V1.0.  Please update this keyword.  Suggest using a scheme where level 2 data sets have "ROICA_1XXX" and level 3 data sets have "ROICA_2XXX" where XXX in both level 2 and 3 are the same for a given phase.  Please feel free to consult with PDS or PSA to figure out the best way to handle this.
--> --> Example suggestion: (not that level 2 VOLUME_IDs below are already locked and cannot change)
--> --> --> for PRL: "ROICA_1009" for level 2 and "ROICA_2009" for level 3.
--> --> --> for ESC1: "ROICA_1010" for level 2 and "ROICA_2010" for level 3.
--> The LABEL_REVISION_NOTE contains notes that are not reflect of this particular volume.  The LABEL_REVISION_NOTE should be unique for the given data set or volume, not for template files.  Also it should only reflect changes to the PDS label or catalog file, not the product it points to.