May 2018 Pre-review Liens list ============================== NH-P/PSA-LEISA/MVIC-5-COMP-V1.0 file: 'catalog/dataset.cat' --> Strongly recommend creating ascii documents with the processing details for each type of data and creating a link to it from the data product label files. Stating to refer to dataset.cat for details is not the correct approach. No need to have so much details in this file. files: 'data/*/*.lbl' --> In the DESCRIPTION it states "See dataset.cat for processing details.". This is not appropriate. There are many PDS ways of doing this, but this is not one of them. Note: NASAview cannot open the QUBE files due to missing BAND_BIN_CENTER keyword. But per the standards this keyword appears to be optional. PDS-SBN is looking into this. files: 'data/color/mvic*.lbl' based on 'mvic_0298719172_0x545_*.lbl' --> Should the mvic*_sci_pl.lbl be SPECTRAL_QUBE instead of QUBE? See section A25 and A25.4.7 of the standards. --> For the '*sci_pl.lbl' files, the CORE_UNIT was changed from "I/F" to "DIMENSIONLESS". We strongly suspect that the CORE_NAME should also be changed, perhaps to "IOF". To be discussed at the review. files: 'data/spec/*.lbl' --> keyword PRODUCT_CREATON_TIME to be renamed PRODUCT_CREATION_TIME. Note the missing 'I'. files: 'data/spec/*{pluto,charon}_cube.lbl' --> keyword PRODUCT_CREATON_TIME to be renamed PRODUCT_CREATION_TIME. Note the missing 'I'. --> MANIPULATED_VALUE: The value, "SPECTRAL_RADIANCE", for "CORE_NAME" is only valid when changed to "SPECTRAL RADIANCE". --> MANIPULATED_VALUE: The value, "WATT*M**-2*SR**-1*uM**-1", for "CORE_UNIT" is only valid when changed to "WATT*M**-2*SR**-1*UM**-1". file: 'data/color/cube_n_color_best.lbl' --> In the RED/NIR/CH4_IMAGE_HEADER, there are two DESCRIPTIONs. I believe the first description should be moved to the corresponding *_IMAGE object.