October 2018 SOHO SWAN Comet Water Production Rates Liens
Version 2 of the Collection
=========================================================

Cesare Grava & Jeff Morgenthaler Science Review
===============================================

Liens fixed by Lori Feaga in communication with data provider
and submitted to Ben Hirsch on 01/09/2020
=============================================================

file: overview.txt
--> This file has been updated in the following ways:  added two directly 
    related references, clarified why the heliocentric velocities and column
    densities are not single valued and therefore not included in the data 
    tables, enhanced the description of the aperture brightness extraction 
    and exclusion of field stars by hand. These changes relate to the 
    scientific queries from the reviewers.
--> In the full collection, this file should replace overview.txt supplied 
    with V1 of the data.
--> **Ben to make sure this replacement happens, Lori has completed all edits.


file: overview.xml
--> This file has an updated publication_year, publication_date, and 
    modification_date.  It is for the V2 overview.txt file listed above. 
--> In the full collection, this file should replace overview.xml supplied 
    with V1 of the data. 
--> **Ben to make sure this replacement happens, Lori has completed all edits.


file: collection.xml
--> The data products' LIDs are not derived from this file's LID:
    urn:nasa:pds:soho:swan_comet_water
    while the product LIDs are:
    e.g. urn:nasa:pds:soho:swan_derived:c_2012_k1_panstarrs_water_tab
    ... (all 13 files)
--> The collection LID has been corrected to urn:nasa:pds:soho:soho:swan_derived
--> Lori has confirmed correctness of data products' LIDs and completed this 
    edit in collection.xml.


file: collection.xml/inventory.xml
--> The inventory file only includes the new data files.  It needs to be 
    reproduced to contain all products in the collection, original and new. 
--> In the full collection, version 2 of the collection.xml supplied here 
    should replace the old collection.xml.  Once the inventory.xml file is 
    created, the number of records needs to be updated in collection.xml.
--> **Ben to make sure the inventory file is created, records attribute is 
    updated, and file replacement happens.


all xml label files: where applicable
--> publication_year/date was updated to 2020 and modification_date was 
    updated if applicable.
--> Lori has completed all edits.


all xml labels reference urn:nasa:pds:context:investigation:mission.soho
except the collection.xml
--> It has been confirmed that mission.soho should be used rather than 
   urn:nasa:pds:context:investigation:mission.solar_and_heliospheric_observatory
    All V1 and V2 data and files are correctly using mission.soho and 
    collection.xml has been corrected.
--> **Ben to consider correcting the mission LIDs in the document collection 
    label files, which incorrectly use 
   urn:nasa:pds:context:investigation:mission.solar_and_heliospheric_observatory
    in the following files: document/collection.xml, 
    document/overview/lasco.xml, soho_mission.xml, soho_spacecraft.xml, and
    swan.xml.  This issue was found when investigating this lien.
--> **Ben while in swan.xml, pleaes fix typo in citation description change 
    (SWAN_ to (SWAN).
--> **Ben to consider correcting the spacecraft LIDs in the document collection 
    label files, which still have TBD in them in the following files: 
    clock_resets_reboots.xml and time_and_rotation_axis.xml, the correct LID 
    is urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument_host:spacecraft.soho.


--> The labels all have references to urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:swan.soho
    Major, please provide a context product for that.
--> **Ben to do/initiate.


--> If SBN wants to provide lid_references to the comets in this collection, 
EN can provide the LIDs.
--> **Ben to do/initiate.


When Ben's few tasks are compelted, this data collection is ready to be archived
- LMF 01/09/2020.

Certification Status: Certified with minor liens