[ERROR] means that there is an error that needs to be fixed. [WARN] means that there may be an error or that there is an error that may be ignored. =============================================== NOTE: (1) Third redelivery. =============================================== Datasets Validated: NH-X-ALICE-2-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-ALICE-3-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-LEISA-2-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-LEISA-3-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-LORRI-2-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-LORRI-3-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-MVIC-2-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-MVIC-3-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-PEPSSI-2-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-PEPSSI-3-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-REX-2-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-REX-3-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-SDC-2-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-SDC-3-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-SWAP-2-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 NH-X-SWAP-3-KEMCRUISE1-V1.0 =============================================== Errors for: GLOBAL (all datasets) [ERROR] TARGET_NAME --> There is no target catalog file for the following targets. PDS SBN can help produce these: --> --> "2012 HZ84" (note should be changed to "ASTEROID 516977 (2012 HZ84)") --> --> "2014 OE394" --> --> "2011 HJ103" --> --> "2012 HE85" --> --> "ASTEROID 119951 (2002 KX14)" --> --> NH: We’ll fix the target names with you. I’ll leave the 2012 HZ84 alone for now and when we rerun data it’ll have better TARGET_NAMEs. file: 'catalog/dataset.cat' --> ABSTRACT_DESC: In the first paragraph they call this mission phase "Kuiper Belt cruise 1 mission phase", but in the data files, they call it "CRUISE TO FIRST KBO ENCOUNTER". Should be consistant. [ERROR] files: 'data/*/*.lbl' --> MISSION_NAME: Change value from "NEW HORIZONS" to "NEW HORIZONS KUIPER BELT EXTENDED MISSION" file: 'voldesc.cat' --> DESCRIPTION: In the first paragraph they call this mission phase "Kuiper Belt cruise 1 mission phase", but in the data files, they call it "CRUISE TO FIRST KBO ENCOUNTER". Should be consistant. =============================================== Errors for only: ALICE [ERROR] file: 'catalog/dataset.cat' --> DATA_SET_DESC: The following paragraph references a file that does not exist. Should there be a sequence file for this mission phase? =================== Every observation provided in this data set was taken as a part of a particular sequence. A list of these sequences has been provided in file DOCUMENT/SEQ_ALICE_PLUTO.TAB. N.B. Some sequences provided may have no corresponding observations. =================== =============================================== Errors for only: LEISA Two raw files were removed from this data set in a prior pre-review delivery when it was mentioned that they were not calibrated in the L3 data set. Please add them back. =============================================== Errors for only: LORRI =============================================== Errors for only: MVIC file: 'catalog/dataset.cat' --> The third paragraph in the DATA_SET_DESC overview section (and within the ABSTRACT_DESC) lists targets that were not observed in this data set. Only M7 was. M6 was not. --> --> NH response: *TARGET issue. M6 is not allowed as a TARGET_NAME so even though some CALIBRATION targets were aimed at M6 we labeled them as CALIBRATION. I removed the mention of M6 for now, but I’d like to ask you about M6 as a TARGET_NAME. --> --> SBN-TB: Re-add the mention. You can change the TARGET_NAME from "CALIBRATION" to "M6" or "NGC 6405". This is a new target, and so we would need to produce a catalog file for it. =============================================== Errors for only: PEPSSI Note that the START_TIME for this mission phase is labeled as being earlier than defined in the mission catalog file. Based on a prior pre-review delivery, data files were removed after it was mentioned that they were labeled as being part of the "PLUTO ENCOUNTER" mission phase. Please note that these files are not found in that data set either. We do not want to lose data. We need to find a home for them. --> --> nh-x-pepssi-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161026_033981/pep_0339745917_0x691_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-pepssi-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161026_033981/pep_0339745917_0x691_sci.lbl =============================================== Errors for only: REX =============================================== Errors for only: SDC Note that the START_TIME for this mission phase is labeled as being earlier than defined in the mission catalog file. Many data files were removed after it was mentioned that they were labeled as being part of the "PLUTO ENCOUNTER" mission phase. Please note that these files are not found in that data set either. We do not want to lose data. We need to find a home for them. --> --> nh-x-sdc-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161017_034136/sdc_0341369528_0x700_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-sdc-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161018_034136/sdc_0341369529_0x700_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-sdc-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161021_034136/sdc_0341369530_0x700_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-sdc-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161024_034136/sdc_0341369531_0x700_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-sdc-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161025_034136/sdc_0341369532_0x700_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-sdc-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161017_034136/sdc_0341369528_0x700_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-sdc-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161018_034136/sdc_0341369529_0x700_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-sdc-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161021_034136/sdc_0341369530_0x700_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-sdc-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161024_034136/sdc_0341369531_0x700_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-sdc-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161025_034136/sdc_0341369532_0x700_sci.lbl =============================================== Errors for only: SWAP START/STOP_TIME --> There are 28 data files (17 raw, 11 calib) that are earlier than the START_TIME specified in the DATASET.CAT file. --> --> NH response: Same issue as others. Need to review what is in P3 and decide on if this belongs or not. Aka delivered already or not… If Heather Elliot cares… --> --> Please note that for the last several days of Oct 2016, we have an overlap of data (based on date, but all different) from the pluto encounter data sets. [ERROR] MISSION_PHASE_NAME --> The following files contain a value of "PLUTO ENCOUNTER": --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161026_033972/swa_0339724800_0x584_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161026_033972/swa_0339724800_0x585_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161026_033981/swa_0339811232_0x586_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161027_033981/swa_0339811200_0x584_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161027_033981/swa_0339811200_0x585_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161027_033989/swa_0339897632_0x586_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161028_033989/swa_0339897600_0x584_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161028_033989/swa_0339897600_0x585_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161028_033998/swa_0339984032_0x586_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161029_033998/swa_0339984000_0x584_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161029_033998/swa_0339984000_0x585_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161029_034007/swa_0340070432_0x586_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161030_034007/swa_0340070400_0x584_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161030_034007/swa_0340070400_0x585_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-2-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161030_034015/swa_0340156832_0x586_eng.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161026_033972/swa_0339724800_0x584_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161026_033981/swa_0339811232_0x586_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161027_033981/swa_0339811200_0x584_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161027_033989/swa_0339897632_0x586_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161028_033989/swa_0339897600_0x584_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161028_033998/swa_0339984032_0x586_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161029_033998/swa_0339984000_0x584_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161029_034007/swa_0340070432_0x586_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161030_034007/swa_0340070400_0x584_sci.lbl --> --> nh-x-swap-3-kemcruise1-v1.0/data/20161030_034015/swa_0340156832_0x586_sci.lbl --> --> NH response: I fixed the DATA_SET_ID and MISSION_PHASE_NAME