Created by SBN:T.Barnes for the Rosetta EARTHBASED data sets. =============================================== Datasets Validated: EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-IFS-V1.0 EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-IMG-V1.0 EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-POL-V1.0 EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-SPEC-V1.0 EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IFS-V1.0 EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0 EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-POL-V1.0 EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-SPEC-V1.0 =============================================== Errors for: GLOABL (all datasets) For those sets of data that cannot be included in the archive due to having data that does not conform to PDS standards, would it be worth putting them into a new data set, and we can SAFE the data set in hopes that someday someone can fix/migrate the data to a compatible format? I would suggest including them in the current data sets, except that would prevent them from being archived. They need to be partitioned off. "GROUND BASED" vs "EARTH BASED". May want to consider changing the verbiage from "GROUND BASED" to "EARTH BASED" since some of these observatories are spacecraft (Ex: Spitzer, HST). Things like VOLUME_NAME, DATA_SET_NAME, and other descriptions would be affected. Missing a target catalog file for TARGET_NAME = ACQUISITION. Perhaps there is another target_name PDS already has ingested that would fit? What is the intention here? SCALING_FACTOR and OFFSET are not being pulled out of the FIT headers into the PDS labels. This makes viewing the data radically different. There are multiple problems in the PDS label for any fits file that has multiple extensions (for data in DATA or CALIB). (1) The objects and pointers are not valid. You must end with the object type, i.e. *_HEADER and *_IMAGE. Also, for the user, it best to keep the text preceding _HEADER and _IMAGE should match if they are related. For instance you could change them to be PRIMARY_HEADER, PRIMARY_IMAGE, STAT_HEADER, STAT_IMAGE. (ex: 'EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IFS-V1.0/DATA/VLT/MUSE/*/67P/3D/*.LBL') (2) The record number in the pointer is grossly wrong for all extensions past the first header/image combination. VLT-UT2/3 --> Many files claim to use the catalog file for VLT-UT1 but change the INSTRUMENT_HOST_NAME to be UT2 or UT3. So either this is a typo in the INSTRUMENT_HOST_NAME in the data labels, or you need to create a new catalog file for VLC-UT2 & UT3 and update the INSTRUMENT_HOST_ID in the data labels + add to dataset/mission catalog files + update UVES & XSHOOTER instrument catalog to show the correct INSTRUMENT_HOST. --> UT2 Affected files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-SPEC-V1.0/DATA/VLT/UVES/ ... /*.LBL' --> UT3 Affected files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-SPEC-V1.0/DATA/VLT/XSHOOTER/ ... /*.LBL' files: 'CATALOG/INST*.CAT' --> Please remember that these files are NOT unique to these data seta and used by other data providers. DO NOT update them with your mission unique information. Adding more information about the instrument or host is fine. --> NONE of these files should have the REFERENCE_KEY_ID of SNODGRASSETAL2017. That paper has nothing to do with these instruments and instrument hosts. If there is a paper that does have important information relating to these instruments and hosts, then that may/should be included here. Otherwise the value should be set to "N/A". --> Please remove the added MISSION_NAME and MISSION_ID. file: 'CATALOG/INST_ISIS.CAT' --> INSTRUMENT_NAME: There is a closing quote on line 18, but the line does not appear to end until line 19. file: 'CATALOG/MISSION.CAT' --> These files must be exactly the same if they are going to be the same mission. Having differences based on data set type is not acceptable. For instance, the Rosetta mission catalog file is exactly the same for all Rosetta mission data sets for all Rosetta instruments. files: '{CALIB,DATA}/SAO_RAS/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_HOST_NAME: value is misspelled "ASROPHYSICAL" => "ASTROPHYSICAL" (note missing 'T') files: '{CALIB,DATA}/VLT/FORS2/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_NAME: value is incomplete. It should match exactly what is in the instrument catalog file. I.e. "FOCAL REDUCER AND LOW DISPERSION SPECTROGRAPH #2 (FORS2)". The last word is missing. files: 'DOCUMENT/*.PDF' --> Files need to be PDF/A-1a or PDF/A-1b compliant. files: 'INDEX/INDEX.{LBL,TAB}' --> These required files are missing and must be generated. PDS-SBN has a tool that could do this if DVAL or PVV cannot. file: 'VOLDESC.CAT' --> VOLUME_ID: value is 18 characters long whereas the max length is 16. Please truncate ID. --> --> Suggest using ROEAR-100x for L2 and ROEAR-200x for L3. 'x' would be 1 to 4 for each type (1 - IFS, 2 - IMG, etc) --> VOLUME_NAME: Please remove "V1.0" from the name. That is covered under VOLUME_VERSION_ID. --> VOLUME_NAME: Several of these values are over the 60 character max limit. Please truncate down. --> For the *IMG* data sets all of the CATALOG object keywords need to be updated. There are many files references that do not actually exist in the CATALOG directory. =============================================== Errors for: *IFS* file: '*IFS*/CATALOG/DATASET.CAT' --> TARGET_NAME: L3 should remove SKY and STAR as targets since they are not found in the data labels. =============================================== Errors for: *IMG* The following data labels claim to be part of the EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-SPEC-V1.0 data set based on DATA_SET_ID and DATA_SET_NAME values. Upon further inspection it appears that these data labels are exact copies of those found in the SPEC data set for files described in the labels. So we are also missing data labels for the files below except with the *.FIT extension. =================== EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_00_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_03_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_06_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_10_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_11_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_15_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_16_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_21_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_23_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_26_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_08/67P/CBU/CH1/SPITZER_I1_1280_28_1_CBUNC.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_01_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_04_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_05_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_06_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_09_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_10_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_11_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_14_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_16_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_18_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_21_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_23_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_24_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_25_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_26_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_27_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_28_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BCD/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_29_1___BCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BIM/CH1/SPITZER_I1_2304_04_1_BIMSK.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BIM/CH1/SPITZER_I1_2304_08_1_BIMSK.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BIM/CH1/SPITZER_I1_2304_11_1_BIMSK.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BIM/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_16_1_BIMSK.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/BIM/CH2/SPITZER_I2_2304_24_1_BIMSK.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/CBC/CH1/SPITZER_I1_2304_14_1__CBCD.LBL EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/SPITZER/IRAC/2016_04_30/67P/CBC/CH1/SPITZER_I1_2304_17_1__CBCD.LBL =================== file: '*IMG*/CATALOG/DATASET.CAT' --> TARGET_NAME: L2 is missing "ACQUISITION" that is found in data labels. Please add. --> START_TIME: There is data in the DATA directory that is before "2014-01-01". Please update this keyword to include those dates. file: '*IMG*/CATALOG/INSTHOST_NEOWISE.CAT' --> INSTRUMENT_HOST_NAME: Correct this value to include "INFRARED". It currently reads "NEAR-EARTH OBJECT WIDE-FIELD SURVEY". Otherwise correct all data labels. file: '*IMG*/CATALOG/INSTHOST_RDLMNOT.CAT' --> INSTRUMENT_HOST_ID: ID should be changed from "RDLMLT" to "RDLMNOT" to match what is used in the instrument catalog files and the data labels. file: '*IMG*/CATALOG/INST_CCDT90.CAT' --> Add INSTRUMENT_HOST_REFERENCE_INFO object. If you have no REFERENCE_KEY_ID, set it to "N/A". files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-IMG-V1.0/CALIB/OSN/ ... /*.LBL' --> For 92 files, the RIGHT_ASCENSION is set to -15, but RIGHT_ASCENSION should only be between 0 and 360. files: '*IMG*/DATA/TRAPPIST/CCD/ ... /*.LBL' --> For 21 L2 and 16 L3 files, the RIGHT_ASCENSION and DECLINATION have no value. If no value is known, then put "UNK" and remove the unit. files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/NEOWISE/ ... /*.LBL' --> TELESCOPE_LONGITUDE: Many of these values are above 180 degrees. The valid range is between -180 and 180. files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/GEMINI/SOUTH/FLAMINGOS2/ ... /*.LBL' --> rename keyword "DECSRIPTION" to "DESCRIPTION" files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/*.LBL' --> DECLINATION: The following files have a value of "87855" which outside the range for DECLINATION. --> --> EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/MOSCA_MORF1_0010_RDR.LBL --> --> EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/MOSCA_MORF1_0011_RDR.LBL --> --> EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/MOSCA_MORF1_0012_RDR.LBL --> --> EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/MOSCA_MORF1_0013_RDR.LBL --> --> EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/MOSCA_MORF1_0014_RDR.LBL --> --> EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/MOSCA_MORF1_0015_RDR.LBL --> --> EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/MOSCA_MORF1_0016_RDR.LBL --> --> EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/MOSCA_MORF1_0017_RDR.LBL --> --> EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/CA/MOSCA/2015_08_18/67P/MOSCA_MORF1_0018_RDR.LBL files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/NOT/ALFOSC/*/67P/S1/*.LBL' --> All but a few dozen of these files have the IMAGE object missing required LINES and LINE_SAMPLES keywords. This prevents the user from reading the file using the label. files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/VLT/FORS2/2014_06_18/67P/*.FIT' --> These files do not have PDS3 labels. files: '*IMG*/{CALIB,DATA}/CA/MOSCA/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_NAME: typo "SPECTROGRAPH" to "SPECTROSCOPY". files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-IMG-V1.0/{CALIB,DATA}/INT/WFC/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_HOST_NAME: typo "GRUPP" => "GRUBB" files: '*IMG*/{CALIB,DATA}/LOWELL/31_INCH/ ... /*.LBL' --> The INSTRUMENT_HOST_NAME does not match the value found in the INSTHOST_LOWELL31IN.CAT. Update the value in the labels. You should drop the word "TELESCOPE". files: '*IMG*/{CALIB,DATA}/LOWELL/DCT/LMI/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_NAME: typo "IMAGE" to "IMAGER". files: 'EAR-C-MULTI_3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/NEOWISE/*/*/*.LBL' --> The INSTRUMENT_HOST_ID is labeled as "SPITZER" for these data even though the directory structure and other identifying information the labels clearly show this to be NEOWISE. files: '*IMG*/{CALIB,DATA}/NOT/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_HOST_ID: should be changed from "NOT" to "RDLMNOT" --> INSTRUMENT_HOST_NAME: should be changed from "THE NORDIC OPTICAL TELESCOPE" to "ROQUE DE LOS MUCHACHOS OBSERVATORY 2.56-M NORDIC OPTICAL/INFRARED CASSEGRAIN ALTAZ. TELESCOPE" files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-IMG-V1.0/{CALIB,DATA}/NOT/ALFOSC/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_NAME: Value here is does not match that found in the instrument catalog file. Please change from "NOT ALHAMBRA FAINT OBJECT SPECTROGRAPH AND CAMERA" to "ALHAMBRA FAINT OBJECT SPECTROGRAPH AND CAMERA (ALFOSC)" files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-IMG-V1.0/{CALIB,DATA}/NOT/STANCAM/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_NAME: typo "(STANDCAM)" => "(STANCAM)". Notice the 'D' being dropped. files: 'EAR-C-MULTI_3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/STELLA/WIFSIP1/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_NAME: Missing "(WIFSIP)" from the end of the name, as is in the instrument catalog file. files: 'EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-IMG-V1.0/DATA/LCOGT/CTIO/SBIG/ ... /*.LBL' --> INSTRUMENT_ID: change from "SBIG_CAM" to "SBIG_CAM_78". =============================================== Errors for: *POL* file: '*POL*/CATALOG/DATASET.CAT' --> TARGET_NAME: L3 should remove SKY as target since it is not found in the data labels. file: '*POL*/CATALOG/INST_HSTACS.CAT' --> INSTRUMENT_ID and INSTRUMENT_HOST_ID values are reversed. The HOST_ID should be HST, and the INST_ID should be HSTACS. file: 'EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-POL-V1.0/DATA/HST/ACS_WFC/*/*/IPOL/*/ ... /*.LBL' --> Any file that has an BINTABLE object, does not describe it correctly. The keywords used describes it as if it were an IMAGE object, but it is a binary TABLE and needs contain the keywords to describe it as such. =============================================== Errors for: *SPEC* GMOS-N instrument is not used in the data set, yet a catalog for it is found CATALOG directory, mentioned in mission/dataset catalog files. The GEMINI-N data files use GNIRS, not GMOS-N. Assuming the data files are correct, please include that instrument catalog file instead. Otherwise update the data file labels to reflect the correct INSTRUMENT_ID/NAME. file: '*SPEC*/CATALOG/DATASET.CAT' --> TARGET_NAME: L2 is missing "ACQUISITION" target that is found in data labels. Please add. file: 'EAR-C-MULTI-2-67P-SPEC-V1.0/DATA/KECK/HIRES/2015_12_26/67P/HI_20151226_48879.LBL' --> The EXT2 and EXT3 pointers point to the wrong file. Please correct. EXT1 does point to the correct file. file: 'EAR-C-MULTI-3-67P-SPEC-V1.0/.DS_Store' --> Delete this file. It should not exist.