September 2019 New Horizons Review 
==================================

ALICE KEM Cruise 1 and KEM1 Encounter Liens
===========================================

Reviewers: John Noonan, Lori Feaga
==================================

file: aareadme.txt
--> The aareadme.txt files looks like they might be missing a revision log entry, contact info changed between last version on PDS, not mentioned in revision.

CATALOG

file: catalog/dataset.cat
--> Under Version, there is text that begins, "Future datasets may include more data...". I'm concerned that the data are being released when they may be potentially incomplete. Thus, are there truly future data to be added to this dataset?

DOCUMENT

file: document/seq_alice_kemcruise1.lbl/tab
--> START_TIME = 2017-01-15T20:10:43 when in fact dataset.cat, index, and data have earliest data start time of 2017-01-11T09:08:01. Please fix the sequence file and label.

file: document/docinfo.txt
--> Typo in the document directory tree – in all 4 datasets. "SEQ_ALICE_KEM1.TAB" listed twice. Fix so that the file extension for the label file is .LBL and not .TAB.

CALIB

file: calib/pa_aeff_*.tab
--> Files contain extra 6 spaces at start of each row but are space delimited. Caused table generation to choke in Python, but quickly found a work around.

file: calib/pa_eff_socc_002.lbl
--> Label states that the values from “pa_aeff_005.tab” are used. Recommend update to use of pa_aeff_007.tab.

Technical Review: Tilden Barnes
===============================

DATA_SET_ID:  Should the KEM1 id not be '-X-' (for "Other") but '-A-' for "asteroid"?  Or are we stating the KBOs are other?

file: 'catalog/dataset.cat'
--> ABSTRACT_DESC: The abstracts between KEMCRUISE1 and KEM1 are almost identical, yet don't they include different things?  Most of the text makes sense for being the same, but I question if what is included is always the same.  Perhaps I'm wrong.
--> DATA_SET_DESC: The difference between KEMCRUIE1 and KEM1 are negligible.  Should that be the case of for a cruise data set and then an encounter?  The purposes and what is observed or done I would think would be different.
--> TARGET_NAME: For KEMCRUISE1, remove the MU69 since it is not a listed target in the data labels.
--> ABSTRACT_DESC: For KEM1, please include mention of MU69, the primary target of this mission phase and of the data in the data directory.

Certification: Certified with liens