February 2020 New Horizons Review ================================= MVIC KEM1 v2.0 Liens ==================== Reviewers: Xiao-Duan Zou, Tony Farnham ====================================== file: dataset.cat --> Units of DN and Calibrated DN are described in the level 3 ds.cat but not level 2. Please add to level 2. --> Misleading line (minor issue): "This version includes data acquired by the spacecraft between 08/14/2018 and 01/31/2019. It only includes data downlinked before 02/01/2019. Future datasets may include mroe data acquired by the spacecraft after 08/13/2018 but downlinked after 01/31/2019." Suggested change "This mission phase includes data... This version of the datasets inlcudes only data downlinked..." --> DATASET.CAT file states that the dataset used to compute geometry is NH-J/P/SS-SPICE-6-V1.0. Dataset is available from NAIF, but coverage ends before this dataset starts (2016) and there isn't a updated set of kernels. Can't check the geometry in the headers and labels without updated kernels. DATA --> When FITS files are read in python, the "error" and "quality flag" extensions don't have names. file: mp2_0408625963_0x530_eng.lbl --> Both the level 2 and level 3 versions of this file are very large and their labels contain issues. In the level 2 file, ^IMAGE pointer is missing. In level 3, the ^EXTENSION_QUALITY_IAMGE pointer is missibng. Certification: Certified w/ minor liens. Don't release until problem file label is fixed.