February 2020 New Horizons Review ================================= REX KEM1 v2.0 Liens =================== Reviewers: Dustin Buccino, Frank Centinello =========================================== file: dataset.cat --> Under the "ABSTRACT_DESC" keyword it states that only data prior to 12/31/2018 are in the dataset, however, there is clearly data taken after. The statement should be updated, and perhaps also included in the data quality/coverage subsection. file: rexdsnjoin.csv --> The file only covers until 2017 and does not include the KEM1 encounters. It should be updated to reflect the DSN activities for KEM1. file: rex_activities_kem1.pdf --> This file includes all REX activities in the encounter sequence, but not all of these are included in the dataset. This is okay but as recommended above dataset.cat should be updated to reflect partial dataset. Richard Chen Engineering Review =============================== nh-a-rex-2-kem1-v1.0/data/tnf/nh_uplink*.lbl nh-a-rex-3-kem1-v1.0/data/tnf/nh_uplink*.lbl - The PRODUCT_IDs in these files don't match index.tab, e.g. nh_uplink_2019003_dss14.lbl has PRODUCT_ID = "NH_UPLINK_2019003_DSS14.TAB" while index/index.tab has ...,"NH_UPLINK_2019003_DSS14.LBL ",...,"NH_UPLINK_2019003_DSS14 ",... Certification: Certified