Re: [EXTERNAL] NH/KEM and R&A data review: details
Subject:
Re: [EXTERNAL] NH/KEM and R&A data review: details
From:
"Chen, Richard L (US 398N)" <richard.l.chen@jpl.nasa.gov>
Date:
2/8/2022, 7:54 AM
To:
Lioudmila Kolokolova <lkolokol@umd.edu>, Elizabeth Warner <warnerem@astro.umd.edu>

Hi, Ludmilla and Elizabeth, my comments are below. I plan to skip the actual review, though if you have some great desire for my presence, I can phone in. Thanks,

Richard



alice5/nh-x-alice-5-ipm-v1.0/data/nh_alice_ipm_scan_countrate.lbl 
- You don't have to fix this, but it's odd:
  PRODUCT_ID = ("NH_ALICE_IPM_SCAN_COUNTRATE")                
Parentheses are for ordered lists, and that keyword needs a single value
- Line 2: the offset for a spreadsheet must be expressed in bytes, so
  ^SPREADSHEET = ("NH_ALICE_IPM_SCAN_COUNTRATE.CSV", 2)
should be
  ^SPREADSHEET = ("NH_ALICE_IPM_SCAN_COUNTRATE.CSV", 1008<BYTES>)
- Line 45: value of ROWS is high by 1; the first line is the file is the header
- Lines 60,73: data type MSB_INTEGER is for binary files. These should
be ASCII_INTEGER.



lorri2/nh-a-lorri-2-kem1-v5.0/catalog/dataset.cat
lorri3/nh-a-lorri-3-kem1-v5.0/catalog/dataset.cat
- Please provide a target.cat for each of
  TARGET_NAME = "136199 ERIS"
  TARGET_NAME = "2018 MG13"
  TARGET_NAME = "2020 KO11"
  TARGET_NAME = "2020 KP11"
  TARGET_NAME = "2020 KR11"
  TARGET_NAME = "2020 KT11"
  TARGET_NAME = "P4856186"
- This target is illegal. Neither PDS3 nor PDS4 has a target
type of spacecraft.
  TARGET_NAME = "VOYAGER 1"

lorri2/nh-a-lorri-2-kem1-v5.0/data/20200606_045371
- Perhaps not a bug: there is no equivalent directory in lorri-3



pepssi4/nh-x-pepssi-4-plasma-v1.0/catalog/dataset.cat
- The only mission here is:
  OBJECT                           = DATA_SET_MISSION
    MISSION_NAME                   = "NEW HORIZONS"
  END_OBJECT                       = DATA_SET_MISSION
Should "NEW HORIZONS KUIPER BELT EXTENDED MISSION" be listed as well?
- Presumably, the trailing , is wrong
    DATA_SET_NAME                  = "                                        
      PEPSSI AVERAGED PLASMA FLUXES AND RATES V1.0,                           
      "                                                                       

pepssi4/nh-x-pepssi-4-plasma-v1.0/data/.../*lbl
- Line 2: the offset for a spreadsheet must be expressed in bytes



swap2/nh-a-swap-2-kem1-v5.0/data/*/*_0x585_eng.lbl
- Perhaps not a bug; these have no equivalent in swap-3



swap5/nh-x-swap-5-derived-solarwind-v2.0/data/nh_sw_20081010_20200127.lbl
- Line 2: the offset for a spreadsheet must be expressed in bytes, so
  ^SPREADSHEET = ( "NH_SW_20081010_20200127.CSV", 2 )
should be
  ^SPREADSHEET = ( "NH_SW_20081010_20200127.CSV", 268<BYTES>)
- Line 54: this is one too high, probably due to the 1 header line
  ROWS = 239253



phaethon/*
- Is there a bundle with LID urn:nasa:pds:gbo-lowell? EN has never ingested
one, and it's not in this review. All LIDs in this collection are prefixed
with that LID.

phaethon/data/.../*.xml
- All (almost all?) labels have
  <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:telescope:lowell.discovery</...>
A similar context product already exists, so presumably change to
  <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:telescope:lowell.discovery_4m3</...>
- The filenames are wrong. E.g. in data/deveny/20171215/extracted/
  c2017o1.cal and c2017o1.cal.xml
should be
  c2017o1.cal and c2017o1.xml

phaethon/data/.../reduced/*.xml
- These all have
  <data_type>SignedMSB2</data_type> 
even though *.fits (except for 1 file in deveny/20171215/reduced) have
  BITPIX  =                  -32

phaethon/data/deveny/.../*.xml
- All (almost all?) labels have
  <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:telescope.discovery.deveny</...>
No LID *deveny* exists yet. The LID should presumably be
  <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:lowell.discovery_4m3.deveny</...>
EN can create this context product if desired.

phaethon/data/lmi/.../*.xml
- All (almost all?) labels have
  <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:telescope.discovery.lmi</...>
A similar context product already exists, so presumably change to
  <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:lowell.discovery_4m3.lmi</...>



On 12/10/21, 08:00, "Lioudmila Kolokolova" <lkolokol@umd.edu> wrote:

    Dear Reviewers and Data Providers,


     Thank you very much for your willingness to participate in the PDS SBN review of the NH/KEM and R&A data. 


    According to the doodle poll, the best dates for the majority of the participants are January 13-14. Some of you are available on one day or only for a specific time. This is OK as the review is virtual, and I can schedule it so that everybody can participate
     as much as possible.


    The review page is https://sbnreview.astro.umd.edu/202201_NH_KEM/ <https://urldefense.us/v3/__https://sbnreview.astro.umd.edu/202201_NH_KEM/__;!!PvBDto6Hs4WbVuu7!ZvwTC7yViDRqwR5_eS9EXhOL65yukZGNWBgkUr2fs3iCW6RIKYMFj2OBbgtv3Wm76-cJ9h4-$>.


    To access the data use
    login: nhk4rev
    password: u%b4Td


    Let me know if you have any questions.


    Thank you again and see you on zoom in January!


    Ludmilla
    =====================================
    Ludmilla Kolokolova
    Planetary Data System Group
    Department of Astronomy
    Rm. 1207D, Atlantic Bldg.
    University of Maryland
    College Park, MD, 20742
    Tel. (301)-405-1539
    http://www.astro.umd.edu/~ludmilla <https://urldefense.us/v3/__http://www.astro.umd.edu/*ludmilla__;fg!!PvBDto6Hs4WbVuu7!ZvwTC7yViDRqwR5_eS9EXhOL65yukZGNWBgkUr2fs3iCW6RIKYMFj2OBbgtv3Wm763KjDbBh$>





    -- 

    Ludmilla Kolokolova
    Planetary Data System Group
    Department of Astronomy
    Rm. 1207D, Atlantic Bldg.
    University of Maryland
    College Park, MD, 20742
    Tel. (301)-405-1539
    http://www.astro.umd.edu/~ludmilla <https://urldefense.us/v3/__http://www.astro.umd.edu/*ludmilla__;fg!!PvBDto6Hs4WbVuu7!ZvwTC7yViDRqwR5_eS9EXhOL65yukZGNWBgkUr2fs3iCW6RIKYMFj2OBbgtv3Wm763KjDbBh$>