Lucy RSS Bundle Liens ====================== Bundle ====== --> The collection titles need to be unique and describe briefly what is different from this collection from the other lucy.rss collections. Currently all the raw collections have exactly the same title. collection: data_cruise1_sff ============================ --> change ODP references to MONTE --> DMASS needs to be defined, but the NAIF documentation does not provide one. SBN may need to intervene here to get a good definition. --> Field AC1_ACC_ON_TIME: Accumulated “on time” is only provided for thruster 1 (there are 16 thrusters). Is the intentional/consisten/expected? If so, it should probably be documented in the description. There is a minor typo in the current description. --> Since fields 15-30 are number of firings for ACS Thrusters the data_type should be an integer as opposed to an ASCII_Real. collection: data_cruise1_skyfreq ================================ --> SOURCE_PRODUCT_ID shows up in Primary Result Summary description. This is PDS3 jargon that needs updating. Also “skyfrequency” should be “sky frequency” --> Field 6 has a description that ends in mid-sentence --> Field 10 has a number of typos in the description --> Accumulated “on time” is only provided for thruster 1 (there are 16 thrusters). Is this intentional/consistent/expected? If so, it should probably be documented in the field description. There is a minor typo in the current description. collection: document ==================== --> No documentation provided. Documentation was expected, but is still being prepared. EN Review ========= data_cruise1_ion/lucy_2022_274_2022_305_ion.xml data_cruise1_sff/*.xml - These have a lid_reference to another unknown LID: urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:lucy.prop If there's debate about what the instrument for such data should be, other similar data reviewed by EN were: urn:nasa:pds:orex.dsn:naf018_sff:* for OSIRIS-REx and urn:nasa:pds:dart:data_maf:* for DART which used the telecommunication system and the high-gain antenna. If there's no debate, that's fine, and please provide a context product. - These have a lid_reference to unknown LID urn:nasa:pds:lucy.rss:document:naf018 The only LID in this bundle's document directory is urn:nasa:pds:lucy.rss:document:rss_info data_cruise1_skyfreq/L25TNFXL02_DPX_220820628_00.xml - This has a lid_reference to unknown LID urn:nasa:pds:lucy.rss:document:naf018 The only LID in this bundle's document directory is urn:nasa:pds:lucy.rss:document:rss_info - Many fields' descriptions say, "If not known or irrelevant, the value -99999.999999 may appear." 1) The .TAB file often has -999.999999 (100x smaller). 2) Suggestion: put such info into a Special_Constant to allow programmatic detection.