lucy.leisa:calibration

*.xml (many, not all)
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>LEISA</name> 
  <name>Fringe Flat</name>
  <name>Space Stare</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
to
  <name>Lucy Ralph Linear Etalon Imaging Spectral Array (LEISA)</name> 
  <name>FLAT FIELD</name>
  <name>SPACE</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo
and one file lucy.misson/document_mission/mission_document.xml had LID
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:$lid



lucy.leisa:data_dinkinesh_calibrated

*.xml (many, not all)
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo

lei_0752129330_02298_sci_04.xml
lei_0752129711_02300_sci_03.xml
lei_0752129956_02302_sci_04.xml
- Each has a lid_reference that doesn't match LIDs in leisa.calibrated. Here:
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.leisa:calibration:lei_0752129330_02298_space
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.leisa:calibration:lei_0752129711_02300_space
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.leisa:calibration:lei_0752129956_02302_space
The LIDs in leisa.calibrated:
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.leisa:calibration:lei_0752129330_02298_space_01
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.leisa:calibration:lei_0752129711_02300_space_01
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.leisa:calibration:lei_0752129956_02302_space_01



lucy.leisa:data_dinkinesh_raw

*.xml (many, not all)
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.leisa:document

*.xml (many, not all)
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
- Suggestion: add lid_reference to target

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo

lralph_ssr.xml
- bug:
  <name>Lucy Ralph Linear Etalon Imaging Spectral Array (LEISA)</name>
    <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:lucy.leisa</lid_reference>
  <name>Lucy Ralph Multispectral Visible Imaging Camera (MVIC)</name>
    <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:lucy.leisa</lid_reference>
Presumably, the second should be urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:lucy.mvic




lucy.llorri:calibration

*.xml (many, not all)
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>L'LORRI</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Long Range Reconnaissance Imager (L'LORRI)</name>

inventory.csv
- Please rename this to collection.csv or collection_inventory.csv;
collection.xml will have to change to match the new name.



lucy.llorri:data_dinkinesh_partially_processed

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
to
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>

collection*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.llorri:data_dinkinesh_raw

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
to
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>

collection*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.llorri:document

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>L'LORRI</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Long Range Reconnaissance Imager (L'LORRI)</name>
- Suggestion: add lid_reference to target

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.ltes:data_dinkinesh_calibrated

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Thermal Emission Sepctrometer (LTES)</name>
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Thermal Emission Spectrometer (L'TES)</name>
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo

tes_0752123018_dinkinesh_sci_01.xml
- The Array_1Ds emission_angle and phase_angle (and others?) have many values
of 9999.0. Add Special_Constants to those Array_1Ds.



lucy.ltes:data_dinkinesh_hkraw

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>The Lucy Thermal Emission Spectrometer (L'TES)</name>
  <name>Lucy Thermal Emission Sepctrometer (LTES)</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Thermal Emission Spectrometer (L'TES)</name>
  <name>Lucy Thermal Emission Spectrometer (L'TES)</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo

tes_0751610627_00000_eng_02.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context product, change
  <name>UNKNOWN</name>
    <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.test_image</...>
to
  <name>TEST_IMAGE</name>
    <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.test_image</...>



lucy.ltes:data_dinkinesh_raw

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Thermal Emission Sepctrometer (LTES)</name>
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
  <name>SPACE_CAL</name>
  <name>INT_CAL</name>
to
  <name>Lucy Thermal Emission Spectrometer (L'TES)</name>
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>
  <name>SPACE</name>
  <name>INTERNAL SOURCE</name>

collection*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.ltes:document

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Thermal Emission Sepctrometer (LTES)</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Thermal Emission Spectrometer (L'TES)</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo
- Suggestion: add lid_reference to target



lucy.mvic:calibration

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>MVIC</name>
  <name>Space Stare</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>Lucy Ralph Multispectral Visible Imaging Camera (MVIC)</name>
  <name>SPACE</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.mvic:data_dinkinesh_calibrated

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.mvic:data_dinkinesh_raw

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.mvic:document

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo
- Suggestion: add lid_reference to target



lucy.rss:data_dinkinesh_ion

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>NASA Deep Space Network Media Calibration</name>
  <name>Global Positioning System</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>DSN Media Calibration</name>
  <name>Deep Space Station Media Calibration Subsystem</name>
- Suggestion: add lid_reference to DSN facility
  urn:nasa:pds:context:facility:observatory.dsn

collection*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
- Suggestion: add the union of the children lid_references, i.e. add
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:planet.earth
Should that replace urn:nasa:pds:context:target:asteroid.152830_dinkinesh,
which no child product has.

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo
- Suggestion: add the union of the children lid_references, i.e. add
  urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:dsn.media
  urn:nasa:pds:context:investigation:other_investigation.media.dsn
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:planet.earth



lucy.rss:data_dinkinesh_sff

*.xml
- Suggestion: for Target_Identification, though the spacecraft acts as
equipment here, still try to match the context product, so change
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <type>Equipment</type>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <type>Spacecraft</type>
- Suggestion: for Observing_System_Component and Investigation_Area,
to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo

collection_inventory.csv
- Typo on line 1:
  P,urn:nasa:pds:lucy.rss:data_dinkinesh_sff:colection_overview::1.0
should be
  P,urn:nasa:pds:lucy.rss:data_dinkinesh_sff:collection_overview::1.0



lucy.rss:data_dinkinesh_skyfreq

*.xml
- Suggestion: use a calibrator target instead of the spacecraft, e.g. one of
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.flat_field
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.internal_source
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.non_science
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.spacecraft_deck
  ...
If you stay with the spacecraft, still match the context product's name
and type, so change
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <type>Equipment</type>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <type>Spacecraft</type>
- Suggestion: for Observing_System_Component and Investigation_Area,
to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Radio Science System</name>
  <name>NASA Deep Space Network</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Radio Science</name>
  <name>Deep Space Network</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo
- Suggestion: add the union of the children lid_references, i.e. add
  urn:nasa:pds:context:facility:observatory.dsn

L*.xml
- Many fields' descriptions describe special values. Add Special_Constants
to those fields to allow automated handling of those. Examples:
  TRANSMIT FREQUENCY - CONSTANT TERM: -999999999.999999
  TRANSMIT FREQUENCY - LINEAR TERM:   -99999.999999
  OBSERVED X-BAND ANTENNA FREQUENCY:  -999999999.999999
  SIGNAL LEVEL:                       -999.9
  DIFFERENTIAL DOPPLER:               -999.999999
  SIGMA OBSERVED ANTENNA FREQUENCY:   -99999.999999
  SIGNAL QUALITY:                     -999.9
  SIGMA SIGNAL LEVEL:                 -999.9



lucy.rss:data_dinkinesh_trk234

*.xml
- Suggestion: use a calibrator target instead of the instrument, e.g. one of
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.flat_field
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.internal_source
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.non_science
  urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibrator.spacecraft_deck
  ...
If not, use the spacecraft as the RSS skyfreq bundle does, i.e. change
  <name>Lucy RSS</name>
    <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:lucy.rss</...>
to
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
    <lid_reference>urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument_host:spacecraft.lucy</...>
If not, then match the context product's name, i.e. change
  <name>Lucy RSS</name>
to
  <name>Lucy Radio Science System</name>
- Suggestion: add lid_reference to DSN facility
  urn:nasa:pds:context:facility:observatory.dsn

- Suggestion: for Observing_System_Component and Investigation_Area,
to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Telecom System</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Radio Science</name>

collection*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Radio Science</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Radio Science</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo
- Suggestion: add the union of the children lid_references, i.e. add
  urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument:dsn.rss

collection_inventory.csv
- the LID of the Product_Collection itself does not go in this file, plus it's
mistyped. collection_overview is missing. So change line 1 from
  P,urn:nasa:pds:lucy.rss:data_dinkinesh_trk234:collectin_inventory::1.0
to
  P,urn:nasa:pds:lucy.rss:data_dinkinesh_trk234:collection_overview::1.0

lucy_2023_*.xml
- The descriptions for fields ul_zheight_corr and dl_zheight_corr in many
tables describe -99.0 as a special value. Add Special_Constants to those
fields to allow automated handling of those.



lucy.rss:document

collection*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Radio Science Subsystem</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Radio Science</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo

rss.pdf
- section 2.3.4.1, typo:
  Where:
  gimcal = always gimcal
  gc = spacecraft number, for Lucy always 49
The last line should be "sc =", not "gc ="


lucy.ttcam:calibration

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>TTCam</name>
  <name>Master Flat</name>
to
  <name>Lucy Terminal Tracking Cameras (TTCAM)</name>
  <name>FLAT FIELD</name>

collection*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.ttcam:data_dinkinesh_calibrated

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
to
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>

collection*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.ttcam:data_dinkinesh_raw

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>DINKINESH</name>
to
  <name>(152830) Dinkinesh</name>

collection*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>TTCam</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Terminal Tracking Cameras (TTCAM)</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo



lucy.ttcam:document

*.xml
- Suggestion: to match the context products, change
  <name>Lucy Spacecraft</name>
  <name>Lucy Mission</name>
  <name>Lucy Terminal Tracking Cameras (TTCams)</name>
to
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy</name>
  <name>Lucy Terminal Tracking Cameras (TTCAM)</name>

collection.xml
- The product in this lid_reference isn't given here. Verify the LID is correct
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucy_mission_info
In the 2023.05 review, many collection.xml had a lid_reference to
  urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mission:document:lucymissioninfo
- Suggestion: add lid_reference to target