Lucy L'Ralph MVIC Liens ======================= Documentation ============= --> Add explanation for why differences exist in labels between between img:exposure_duration, the delta of start_date_time and stop_date_time, lucy:mvic_observation_allocation, and lucy:mvic_tdi_row_integration_time. file: overview.txt --> Include a short explanation of the 2D calibration coefficient (the 6 x 5024 arrays in the calibrated image bundles) for users, e.g., clarifying what the rows and columns represent. Same suggestion applies to the Background Table. --> Include simple equations in the overview showing how the background & calibration coefficients are applied during calibration to produce the final calibrated outputs. file: 'readme.txt' --> The Calibrated collection sections say they are "partially processed images", but it should say "calibrated". Data ==== --> In raw and calibrated data, a half-and-half pattern and clusters of negative pixels are see on the right side in Bands 3, 5, and 6, but are not shown in the corresponding calibration files. Explain source of issue in documentation. --> Explain image selection reasoning (why only five images were calibrated) in documentation OR add missing data. --> --> The Lucy team has generated and provided the five missing calibrated products. However, the instrument team says: These data are point source observations, so although they possibly could be used for light curve analysis, they suffer from the bimodal noise, so they are not overly useful in current form. Labels ====== file: *.xml --> Typo in Lucy LDD attribute: mce_start_postion -> mce_start_position, mce_end_postion -> mce_end_position. Discuss with dictionary stewards and SBN personnel as to how/whether to fix. --> Add units of radiance for calibrated data. --> For raw data labels without corresponding calibrated data, remove the data_to_calibrated_product internal reference. file: 'bundle.xml' --> Missing the File_Area_Text class for the readme.txt file. file: 'calibration/collection.xml' --> The Modification_Detail date and description for version 1.0 has changed to match that of version 2.0, but it should be for the Dinkinesh delivery. Please fix. --> values were added to the internal_references in the Reference_List in Dinkinesh, but removed here. Please add back. files: 'data_donaldjohanson_*/collection_overview.xml' --> The LID for these files says dinkinesh, but it should be for donaldjohanson. Please correct the logical_identifier. file: 'data_donaldjohanson_raw/collection_inventory.csv' --> The LID for the overview document is misspelled. "collection_ovrview" => "collection_overview" file: 'document/collection.xml' --> Update the from 2024 to be 2025. --> The Citation_Information.doi is for the prior version of this collection. It should be replaced with a new DOI value. --> The inventory file is incomplete, only containing the updated product, not including the non-versioned products. file: 'document/collection_inventory.csv' --> When versioning a collection, the collection inventory files should contain a full list of products (best copy usually), not just new or updated products. Please add back all the products from v1.0 of this collection. EN Liens ======== *.xml - The document/ dir and any associated SIS were not part of this review, but many files have a lid_ or lidvid_reference to urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:document:mvic_sis Please ensure this will be available in the real bundle. bundle.xml - This has lid_references to collections not in the bundle under review: urn:nasa:pds:lucy.ltes:data_dinkinesh_calibrated::1.0 urn:nasa:pds:lucy.ltes:data_dinkinesh_raw::1.0 Please ensure those collections will still be in the real bundle. - Since readme.txt exists, bundle.xml should point to it, something like readme.txt 0 7-Bit ASCII Text Carriage-Return Line-Feed between Bundle and Bundle_Member_Entry - Suggestion: since labels in this bundle have them, add lid_references to urn:nasa:pds:context:target:asteroid.52246_donaldjohanson urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibration_field.space calibration/collection.xml - Suggestion: since labels in this collection have it, add lid_reference to urn:nasa:pds:context:target:calibration_field.space - This lidvid_reference has no corresponding label: urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:calibration:collection_overview::1.0 The LID is also listed in calibration/collection_inventory.csv collection/collection_inventory.csv - This lists many LIDs not available in this review: urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:calibration:mvi_0752129246_02297_space::1.0 urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:calibration:mvi_0752129547_02299_space::1.0 urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:calibration:mvi_0752129862_02301_space::1.0 urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:calibration:mvic_radcal_tdi16::1.0 urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:calibration:mvic_radcal_tdi32::1.0 urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:calibration:mvic_radcal_tdi4::1.0 urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:calibration:mvic_radcal_tdi64::1.0 urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:calibration:mvic_radcal_tdi8::1.0 Please ensure they'll exist in the delivered bundle, or modify this file. data_donaldjohanson_calibrated/collection_overview.xml - This file's LID is ...:data_dinkinesh_calibrated:... instead of ...:data_donaldjohanson_calibrated:... data_donaldjohanson_raw/collection_overview.xml - This file's LID is ...:data_dinkinesh_calibrated:... instead of ...:data_donaldjohanson_calibrated:... data_donaldjohanson_raw/mvi_0798391044_02539_eng_03.xml & 4 more - These have no equivalent in directory data_donaldjohanson_calibrated/, and each of these five labels has a (missing) lid_reference to the equivalent, e.g. urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:data_donaldjohanson_calibrated:mvi_0798391044_02539_sci Please ensure those labels and data files will be in the real bundle. document/ - Many labels have lid_references to urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:document:mvic_sis which is neither provided nor listed in collection_inventory.csv in this review. Please ensure that it exists in the delivered version. document/collection.xml - This lidvid_reference has no corresponding label: urn:nasa:pds:lucy.mvic:document:collection_overview::1.0