=============================================== NOTE: (1) For 2025-10 peer review. =============================================== Datasets Validated: urn:nasa:pds:compil-comet:comet_afrho::1.0 =============================================== Comments for: urn:nasa:pds:compil-comet:comet_afrho::1.0 Is it a problem that this collection uses *.lblx PDS4 label extension, whereas the rest of the bundle uses *.xml? file: 'collection.lblx' --> Please change the Reference_List entry for the overview document from LID to LIDVID. --> SBN should generate a DOI for this collection and put it into this file. file: 'overview.txt' --> The last sentence contains a list of items, but their is not "and" before the last item. Should probably define what the TYPE values mean in the Small Bodies Database beyond the name, for instance orbits. The Small Bodies Database may not always exist so it would be best to capture this information. I generated a listing many years ago, but it may need to be updated: https://pdssbn.astro.umd.edu/data_other/objclass.shtml Should probably define what each value in the BAND column stands for. Should this collection and/or data product cite (add to Reference_List + DOI meta data) each and every paper that it is referencing? Fortunately there are columns in the data file that provides this information.